Any Current New York Players on Way to Cooperstown?

Any Current New York Players on Way to Cooperstown?
Fact Checked by Pat McLoone

Every sport has a pinnacle for individual success, and nothing cements lifetime achievements quite as much as a spot in the hall of fame.

Fans of baseball and New York sports betting know only a select few ever will attain a spot in the Hall of Fame in Cooperstown.

The 2023 MLB Hall of Fame ceremony is on July 23 with Fred McGriff and Scott Rolen being inducted.

To be eligible for the Hall of Fame, MLB players must have played at least 10 seasons and must be retired for at least five years. Players such as David Wright, Dustin Pedroia, CC Sabathia and Troy Tulowitzki will be eligible in the next couple of years, along with other strong names who recently have retired and are biding their time.

With all of this Hall of Fame chatter before the 23rd, – your source for New York sportsbook promos - has decided to see which active MLB Players are bound for the Hall of Fame and if any of them have made their marks for the New York teams.

We utilized’s Hall of Fame monitor stat to see which current players are likely headed to Cooperstown. Using its rough scale, 100 means there is a good possibility of induction and 130 or above is virtually a lock for the Hall.

Must be 21+ to participate & present in NY. Gambling problem? Call (877-8-HOPENY) or text HOPENY (467369). Visit for Terms & Conditions. US promotional offers not available in NY, NV, or Puerto Rico.

Most Likely Active Hall of Famers

Here is analysis you won’t find on any legal New York betting apps.

PlayerHOF Monitor ValueCareer StatsAccolades
Miguel Cabrera293.307/.383/.521, 508 HR, 3,128 H12X All Star, 2X MVP, 1X Triple Crown
Justin Verlander234247-137, 3.25 ERA, 3,255 Ks9X All Star, 3X Cy Young, 2X ERA Title, 1X MVP
Clayton Kershaw213207-91, 2.48 ERA, 2,912 Ks10X All Star, 3X Cy Young, 5X ERA Title, 1X MVP
Max Scherzer177209-105, 3.15 ERA, 3,294 Ks8X All Star, 3X Cy Young
Jose Altuve161.306/.362/.468, 198 HR, 1,967 H8X All Star, 6X SS, 3X Batting Title, 1X MVP
Mike Trout153.301/.412/.582, 368 HR, 940 RBI11X All Star, 9X SS, 3X MVP, ROY
Nolan Arenado122.288/.345/.534, 318 HR, 1.030 RBI10X GG, 8X All Star, 5X SS
Craig Kimbrel11546-37, 2.37 ERA, 408 SV, 1,155 Ks9X All Star, ROY
Zach Greinke114224-150, 3.48 ERA, 2,946 Ks6X All Star, 6X GG, 1X Cy Young
Paul Goldschmidt105.295/.390/.524, 330 HR, 1,088 RBI7X All Star, 5X SS, 4X GG, 1X MVP


No current player is more certain to be a Hall of Famer five years after retirement than Detroit’s Miguel Cabrera. Cabrera has spent most of his career with the Tigers and has 508 career home runs. He has 12 seasons with at least 100 RBI, including 11 in a row at one point in his career.

His best years came in 2012 and 2013 when he won AL MVP awards. Cabrera will retire as a no doubt future Hall of Famer.

A trio of dominant pitchers follow Cabrera on the list. Justin Verlander, Clayton Kershaw and Max Scherzer have nine combined Cy Youngs and two MVP trophies to go along with a bevy of All-Star game appearances.

Jose Altuve, Mike Trout and Nolan Arenado follow them on the list with many accomplishments. Trout and Altuve have at least one MVP award and Arenado is one of the best defensive players of his generation, as evidenced by his 10 Gold Glove awards.

What About Mets, Yankees?

While current studs like Aaron Judge, Pete Alonso, Gerrit Cole and potentially more might build on potential Hall of Fame cases over the coming years, the only New York area players currently on the top 10 list are two of the dominant pitchers winding their careers down with the Mets in Scherzer and Verlander.

It is highly unlikely the pair can add another World Series to their resumes this season. FanDuel New York has the Mets +7500 to win it all, which is tied for 19th with Cleveland among 30 MLB teams.

Verlander had a resurgence last season with the Astros, winning the AL Cy Young and his second World Series and he parlayed that success into a two year, $86.67 million contract with the Mets. Verlander has yet to find the same level of success in New York. At his age, he is unlikely to get back to that form.

Scherzer is making the same amount of money per year as Verlander with the Mets as he is in the second year of a three-year, $130 million pact. He has eight wins on the year, but his 3.99 ERA is the highest he’s had since 2011 as he also shows signs of slowing down. Despite the drop in play, both of these players have put together sterling resumes and will no doubt be heading to the Hall of Fame.



Cecil Peters is a Senior Betting Analyst for A professional sports bettor in Canada, Cecil specializes in analyzing the latest odds impacting professional sports teams, with a focus on a league's favorite players and teams. In New York, that includes his specialty, the NHL, and the Rangers, Islanders and Sabres.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: