New York NFL Betting Sites: NY NFL Sportsbooks May 2024

Fact Checked by Lawrence Hollyfield

Looking for the best NFL sports betting sites in New York? I have reviewed all New York sportsbooks by legality, user experience and odds/betting options, plus available bonuses and odds boosts to help you bet on the NFL successfully.

Best NFL Betting Sites in New York

You know all the legal NY Sportsbooks options available, but who has the best offering for NFL bettors?  

Verified Offers Verified By Our Experts
Best Choice
Fanatics Sport
Best Choice
Must be 21+ to participate. T&Cs Apply.
Must be 21+ to participate & present in NY. Gambling problem? Call (877-8-HOPENY) or text HOPENY (467369). Visit for Terms & Conditions. US promotional offers not available in NY, NV, or Puerto Rico.

My Criteria For Picking The Top NFL Betting Sites in New York

I – and all of us at – use several factors when considering which NFL betting sites to recommend:

  • Safety All of the top NFL sportsbooks I recommend are licensed and regulated in New York. That means your personal information and funds are protected, a must for any operator that wants to be considered among the best online sportsbooks.
  • User Experience It's quick and easy to sign up with a New York NFL betting site. You should have plenty of payment options and be able to access your winnings quickly. Customer service should be responsive and NY mobile sports betting apps should be convenient to use. One of the best NFL sportsbooks available is BetRivers NY, as its app's user experience is one of the best among online betting sites in the state.
  • Competitive NFL Odds And Betting Options I look at the odds for the NFL games provided by each site to ensure that not only are they plentiful but also that you get value as well. All NFL betting websites must offer plenty of live-betting options, and if they don't, I’ll let you know that as well.
  • Bonuses And Boosts I check out the bonuses offered by the best NFL betting sites in New York to make sure they are fair and attainable. I also look for New York sportsbooks that offer NFL odds boosts and risk-free bets – and not just to new customers. One of the best NFL betting websites for welcome bonuses is Caesars Sportsbook NY.

How To Sign Up For A New York Online NFL Betting Site

Online sports betting with a legal NFL online site never has been easier. The first step is to find the right New York operation for your given needs. Then the site will ask you for personal information to get you logged in.

Most legal sports betting sites will ask you to confirm the last four digits of your Social Security number, so be aware of that when signing up. You will also be asked for a driver’s license, passport and/or utility bill to further establish your identity. You then can make a deposit and bet on the NFL.

Deposit And Withdrawal Methods For New York NFL Online Sportsbooks

Most online NFL betting sites offer many different ways to deposit and withdraw funds. Here are a few of the football betting sites' most popular options for New York players:

Credit/Debit Card

This is the most popular way for players to deposit money into an online sportsbook. Not all financial institutions allow gambling transactions, even though they are completely legal. Other banks will treat them like cash advances and charge big fees. Check with your card issuer.


Another popular way for New Yorkers to deposit money into online NFL betting sites is through an e-wallet, with the most common being PayPal. Typically, sites that allow services such as PayPal will enable you to withdraw winnings from the same account.

You can also fund your PayPal account with a credit card.

Play+/Prepaid Cards

Play+ was designed for online betting and works well. You can fund a Play+ card with a credit card or bank account, then move funds in and out of your online sportsbook account.

When you want to access the cash, go to an ATM. Additionally, prepaid cards – which are available at retail stores and from some New York online sportsbooks – can be used. These work like credit or gift cards but have a predetermined amount of money loaded onto the card.

Bank Transfer

Move funds from your bank account to the online NFL betting site and back.

Bonuses And Promotions For NFL Betting

Many online NFL betting sites offer bonuses and sportsbook promo codes in New York to get players to sign up. Sites often will allow players to have free NFL bets, odds boosts, and deposit matches to get players wagering on their sites.

Be sure to research the potential bonuses and read the terms and conditions before making your first deposit. 

Must be 21+ to participate & present in NY. Gambling problem? Call (877-8-HOPENY) or text HOPENY (467369). Visit for Terms & Conditions. US promotional offers not available in NY, NV, or Puerto Rico.

Reading NFL Lines And Odds

There are a few things to know before placing a bet on NFL games online. The most important is to understand how to read NFL betting odds.

Moneyline odds are expressed as +/-, with - indicating the favorite and + indicating the underdog.

A -125 favorite means a player would need to bet $125 to win $100. A +150 underdog is the opposite. A player would need to wager $100 to win $150. It’s important to note that bets don’t need to be made in $100 increments. Many NFL betting sites allow a minimum bet of $1 or even less.

Alongside moneyline bets in New York, you typically will see spread odds. A favorite might be -2.5 points, so the underdog is +2.5. 

And the final set of odds is for totals betting. You may see O 65.5 and U 65.5 as your options, meaning you can bet on the total combined points to either go over or under 65.5 points.

Types Of NFL Bets

  • NFL Moneyline Bets A moneyline wager is a bet on which team will win the game. Ties are rare in the NFL – with just one occurring in each of the past three seasons – but in the event of a tie, your moneyline stake would be refunded.
  • NFL Point Spreads A point spread bet is the most common method of NFL betting. Oddsmakers for NFL betting sites project the number of points the favorite is expected to win by in an upcoming game. New York bettors determine whether the favorite (- points) can cover the point spread or if the underdog (+ points) can win or stay within a given number of points. Odds on either side of the bet tend to be around -110. They are particularly useful when you want to bet on your favorite team but it is a huge underdog.
  • NFL Futures Players wager on an outcome that will happen in the future, hence the name. Examples of futures bets include who will win the MVP award, a team's season win total or who will win the Super Bowl. These bets can be placed during the off-season or regular season. NFL betting sites pay out users at the end of the season or the end of the playoffs, depending on the bet.
  • Over/Under NFL Wagers In each game, oddsmakers pick the total points that will be scored in a given contest, and NFL bettors are asked to wager if the total will go over or under. Any points scored in overtime count toward the over/under bet, unless otherwise noted.
  • NFL Parlay Bets A parlay bet is when two or more selections are combined into a single bet. Parlay bets have increased odds and all individual bets need to be “won” for the entire bet to hit. So if one leg of your parlay loses, the entire bet will be graded a loss. This is one of the riskier NFL betting methods for New York players. However, even when your team looks like it has no hope of winning, you can still enjoy betting on the game and even make some money.
  • NFL Prop Bets Prop bets – an abbreviation of proposition betting – are a method of NFL betting allowing players to wager on specific outcomes within a game. This can be the number of touchdowns for a player, receiving yards, receptions, etc. The number and variety of prop bets differ for each site, so make sure you shop and check out all the different prop bet options at your favorite NFL betting sites.
  • NFL Teaser Bets A teaser is a form of a parlay bet where all the odds in each leg are shifted by the same number of points in the bettor’s favor. The lower lines are more likely to hit the players. However, these bets have lower odds in exchange.

Is There More To NFL Betting Than Just Games?

Yes. Several New York NFL betting sites allow wagering on the NFL draft, free agency and so much more. Plus, players can bet on multiple other sports at their favorite sportsbook, including college football, baseball, hockey, tennis, professional and college basketball, and more.

Of course, Super Bowl betting in New York in New York is the biggest game out there.

10 Tips If You Bet On NFL Games

Make sure you understand these suggestions before you start betting.

1. Find The Best NFL Betting Sites For New York Sports Bettors

The best piece of advice I can give is to find the right online sportsbook for your needs. Some New York sportsbooks will offer promotions, odds boosts and bonuses on given games, and others will payout quicker.

NFL online betting is more fun when you find the best NFL betting site makes the experience that much more enjoyable. When you win, you want to be paid right away and accurately.

You also want NFL sportsbooks that are easy to navigate and has all the latest NFL betting odds. Once you find the online sportsbooks that make sense, you can begin enjoying the process.

2. Shop Around For Prices When NFL Betting

Odds on NFL games, spreads, and totals vary depending on the online sportsbook. So, once you have decided on the game on which you want to bet, take a look at two or three other New York sites to see if you can get better odds.

More often than not, you can find better value if you take 10-15 minutes to shop around for a better NFL betting line.

3. Don't Wager Your Balance On One NFL Game

While there is a temptation to put all of your bankrolls on one game that you know is a lock, avoid doing so as upsets occur. Bankroll management and discipline are huge when it comes to NFL betting strategy.

Parity is a real thing in the NFL game – it is the league of "on any given Sunday." Never invest more than you can afford to lose in a single game, no matter the sport.

4. Monitor Lines Throughout The Week

NFL betting lines can change as New York bettors begin wagering on the game. Monitor the lines throughout the week to see if they are changing. At the same time, remember to shop around for the best prices to ensure you are getting the most value.

5. You Don't Have To Bet Every Week

This is another mistake new NFL bettors make. Over the 18-week NFL season, New York players should not feel obligated to bet on every slate. Skipping the week or dialing back the amount you are betting is commendable, and a wise long-term maneuver.

6. Think Of Betting Like Investing

While NFL betting is supposed to be fun, consider the process to be an investment as well. You want to build your bankroll over time. If you can win 53% of your bets, you will see your bankroll gradually increase and you will enjoy watching and betting on the NFL even more.

7. Don't Bet On NFL Games Like A Fan

Always endeavor to wager with your head and not your heart. Avoid betting on your favorite team – unless you perceive an objective edge – as bettors often can't think clearly when it comes to their allegiances.

8. Be Mindful Of Trends, But Don't Be A Slave To Them

It's important to know which teams play well at home and on the road, but it's more important to know which trends to value and which to ignore. Bettors can be misguided by trends now and again.

Don't ignore all trends in favor of your gut, but be informed about the upcoming game you have chosen.

9. Check Injury Reports

Make sure you know who is in and out for the upcoming NFL football games. Certain players and positions can swing lines, so pay attention to those early-week injury reports to find out who will and won't be on the field.

10. Have Fun

The reason so many people use the best NFL betting sites is to further their enjoyment of the league. They like to have a little skin in the games when their favorite team isn't playing.

Betting shouldn't be a chore. Instead, it should be fun. Make sure to find the right balance of being informed and still enjoying the action happening on the field.

Why is Betting On NFL Games So Popular?

The NFL is the most popular sport in the United States, and this certainly applies to New York. Most football betting sites offer a variety of ways to bet on NFL contests, including individual matchups, team futures, player prop bets and so much more.

Additionally, online betting sites such as WynnBET Sportsbook NY offer some of the best perks for NFL fans. If you're going to bet, go with the best.

New York NFL Betting Sites FAQ


Joss Wood is a Senior Writer for Joss is globally considered one of the leading voices in the gambling industry, especially North American sports betting.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: