Best NY MLB Betting Sites 2023 Baseball Season

Baseball is a fantastic sport for wagers. There are games every night of the week for six months. Limitless parlays and prop bets are available. Live betting is intense. These online betting sites in New York all offer beautiful baseball bets. 

Another great betting option in baseball comes in the offseason as bookmakers and bettors react to free agent signings. Pitchers and catchers have reported, so the season is coming down on us quickly.

Yankees/Mets Odds To Win 2023 World Series

The New York teams signed Aaron Judge and Justin Verlander to gear up for a run in 2023.

⭐️ BetRiversYankees, +1400Mets, +2200Use $100 promo
⭐️ BetMGMYankees, +1300Mets, +4000Explore BetMGM
⭐️ FanDuel SportsbookYankees, +1500Mets, +4500$1,000 No Sweat First Bet

Odds last updated June 20, 2023.

There are plenty more sportsbooks with baseball offers out there. Check out all NY sportsbooks and add some to your portfolio before the season starts.

Best Baseball Betting Sites for New York Sports Wagering

Verified Offers Verified By Our Experts
Best Choice
Fanatics Sport
Best Choice
Must be 21+ to participate. T&Cs Apply.
Must be 21+ to participate & present in NY. Gambling problem? Call (877-8-HOPENY) or text HOPENY (467369). Visit for Terms & Conditions. US promotional offers not available in NY, NV, or Puerto Rico.

There are thousands of dollars in welcome offers and promotions that you can access by opening accounts at more than one NY sportsbook.

How To Choose The Best MLB Betting Site In New York

From innings played to caught-stealing percentage, there are a lot of numbers in MLB stats. All of that data stretching back more than 100 years makes for data that New York online sportsbooks can use to offer great betting options – and New York promo codes – for baseball fans.

MLB games have enough range in scoring to make spread betting interesting. In short, MLB games offer lots of opportunities for fans to enjoy a gamble no matter how deep their knowledge of the stats.

Here’s what we look for:

  • Safety of a Baseball Betting Site We make sure each recommended online wagering is licensed and regulated by the gaming authority in the state where it operates. We will never recommend an offshore betting operator as one of the best MLB betting sites because they are risky and unregulated. By going through a licensed bookmaker, you know your information and funds are secure.
  • User Experience of Online Betting Both New York sports betting apps and websites alike should be user-friendly, intuitive and welcoming. Signing up should be hassle-free, depositing and withdrawing funds quick, and customer service and support must be top-notch.
  • Baseball Betting Options Every recommended betting website will have a ton of MLB odds and markets, and all betting sites should have features such as point spread betting, futures odds, live betting, and much more.
  • Bonus, Promo Codes & Risk-Free Bets We look for the best betting promo codes in New York and make sure the terms are fair. We also look for operators with great VIP plans, parlay insurance, and odds boosts. Anyone looking to bet on baseball, or on any sport for that matter, should take advantage of promo codes and welcome bonuses. Some online sports betting options that New York bettors can use to their advantage include BetMGM NY, and WynnBET NY. These online bookmakers all offer sign-up offers that are both lucrative and enticing to new sports bettors.

Why Bet on Baseball Games Online?

For the serious sports bettors - and even the casual ones - one of the biggest appeals of baseball is the sheer number of games. There are 162 of them in an MLB season, then the playoffs. Every week, there are more than 100 different team matchups.

Like the sport itself, betting on baseball is a more casual experience than, say football betting in New York or basketball betting in New York, where points are scored freely and easily and the lines can change just as quick.

Baseball is the only major sport with no time clock, so the game you’re betting on could last two hours, or it could last all night with extra innings.

Betting on baseball appeals to the gut gambler who just wants to let it ride on one game (“I got the Yankees tonight on the Moneyline, the wind’s blowing in and the ace of the staff is on the hill!”) as well as the math nerd who likes to pore over pages and pages of analytics, looking for long-term trends.

Can I Bet on Baseball in All States?

No, but the list is growing every year. You can only legally bet on baseball in states that have passed legislation allowing the regulated establishment of brick-and-mortar and/or online betting sites. Entering 2023, nearly 30 states have legalized sports betting either in-person or mobile or both. By the end of 2023, it is expected that at least 35 states will have officially sanctioned legal sports betting.

You can sign up and bet on an MLB betting site in two easy steps:

  • ✅ Pick a site from our peer-reviewed, carefully cultivated list.
  • ✅ Be ready with the following information: photo ID (driver’s license or passport), full name and address, email, birthday, proof of address and payment method.
Must be 21+ to participate & present in NY. Gambling problem? Call (877-8-HOPENY) or text HOPENY (467369). Visit for Terms & Conditions. US promotional offers not available in NY, NV, or Puerto Rico.

Deposit and Withdrawal Options for MLB Betting Sites

Once your account is set up, choose the deposit option that makes the most sense for you. That could be Play+, PayPal, Visa, bank transfer, etc. If you win your bet, you can count on your money being transferred to your account in 3-5 days with no fees, if you do direct deposit. If you want to get your money instantly, there is usually a small fee, usually no more than 1 percent of the deposit total.

What Bonuses and Promotions are Offered for MLB Betting

When you sign up for an online wagering site, you will be eligible for a variety of bonus offers. Many online betting site listed here offer great deals for first-time customers, and among the most common is a first deposit match.

The online sports gambling operator will match your first deposit dollar-for-dollar, though there are often wagering requirements, so make sure to read the terms and conditions.

Other bonuses may include a no-deposit bonus, which is typically a small amount of free money to wager with; a risk-free first wager, meaning if you lose your first bet, your operator will give you that amount back in free bets; and odds boosts in New York for select contests.

How to Read MLB Betting Lines and Odds

The most basic MLB betting line is the Moneyline, where your task is just to pick the winning team in the game, period. Odds will be given by the bookmaker, with a minus sign (-150) signifying the favored team and a plus sign (+135) signifying the underdog.

If you bet on the team listed at -150, that means you have to bet $150 to win $100. If you bet the underdog to win at +135, that means you bet $100 to win $135. You don’t have to bet in $100 increments.

You can bet a team to win on the run line, but the spread for a baseball game is almost always 1.5 runs. If you give 1.5 runs, your team must win by two runs or more. The odds are greater, but so is the risk.

There will be an over-under bet available on the number of runs scored in a game by both teams. The most frequent number of combined runs in a game, at least in recent years, is seven, but the best-hitting teams will have a higher “total” to bet the over-under, and the odds will be adjusted in kind.

Types of MLB Bets to Place

There are several types of bets that baseball fans can make on MLB betting sites. Learn more about the different types of baseball bets that you can make with online baseball betting sites below, and place these bets with New York sports betting platforms such as BetRivers NY, FanDuel NY.

  • Moneyline Bets Moneyline bets in NY are among the simplest forms of MLB betting. The bettor simply bets on who will win the game.
  • Over/Under Over/Under betting in New York is the combined number of runs scored by both teams in a game (extra innings count). Betting totals is one of the most popular bets.
  • Run Line Most likely, the game will have a spread of +/-1.5 runs (which in baseball is called the “run line”). If you think the Yankees will beat the Red Sox by two runs or more, then you want to bet the Yankees at -1.5. Your payout will be higher than betting Moneyline odds.
  • Team Totals A bet where you wager the over-under for just one team on the number of runs it will score. If the other team’s ace is on the mound, the under is likely to be your most popular wager on his opponent’s run total.
  • Prop Bets Think Aaron Judge will hit a home run for the Yankees tonight, and that’s all you want to bet on? You can, on a prop bet. Prop bets typically have higher payouts than other bets.
  • Futures Bets Are you just absolutely convinced the Houston Astros will win the World Series? You can bet on that happening with an MLB futures bet. The odds for every team will be posted before the season and updated throughout.
  • Parlay Bets Do you think the Dodgers and Astros will both win their games tonight? Bet it, then, on a parlay. Your payout will be higher than a single-game bet, but both teams must win to cash your ticket.
  • Live Betting Whether MLB bettors are watching a game live or on TV, there are plenty of live betting lines at various MLB betting sites.

What MLB Games Can I Bet On?

Baseball odds are so much more than just games and World Series betting. You can make an MLB futures bet on individual player trophies all year long, with the best odds typically before the season starts. If you think Aaron Judge will be the American League MVP, you can bet on it.

Same with the Cy Young winners in each league, the ERA champion, Gold Gloves winners, the home-run leader and more.

In addition to every regular-season game, you can also bet on team win totals, division and league winners, the All-Star Game and Home Run Derby, postseason series, and more.

Quick MLB Betting Tips to Consider

Baseball is a game in which a dizzying array of numbers will always be coming at you, so it’s important to have a decent grasp of deciphering them.

No, you don’t need to be Albert Einstein, but you want to know the basics. Let's take a look at some quick MLB betting tips that you should know before betting on any MLB games in New York.

Know Who's Pitching

Get to know the pitchers in both leagues. A pitcher with a great won-loss record and low ERA is a guy whose team you’re going to feel comfortable putting some cash down on the Moneyline, or the under total.

A team trotting out its fifth starter with a mediocre-to-poor record is a guy you may want to fade. It’s essential that the serious MLB bettor know the pitchers for the game, and that means getting those matchups early in the day when they’re posted.

Weather During MLB Games

Another thing to consider: weather. While more baseball stadiums have enclosed fields, many others are still subjected to conditions that are the whim of Mother Nature. Check those weather forecasts for a game with an outdoor field.

Does the forecast call for the wind to blow straight out to the left-field that night? You might want to bet the over then. Does it call for blustery, cold conditions? That could affect the hitters and you may want to back the under.

Follow MLB Betting Writers

You should follow the Twitter accounts of established MLB beat writers, because they’ll often have real-time updates on lineup changes, injuries, ejections, etc. Read team websites before making your MLB picks too, because they’ll often have recent quotes from the manager on various team plans, development, etc.

Be Cautious of "Systems"

A lot of bettors believe in “systems” betting, such as betting the underdog at a higher percentage over the long haul, in the belief that higher payouts will accrue into plus territories than betting the straight favorites at a lower juice. One person’s system may be folly to another, however, and there are many “system” players who came to regret their rigid adherence to it.

That said, things do tend to “average out” in the long haul in baseball, so finding a system that works for you can be very profitable.

Manage Your Bankroll

Perhaps the most important tip of all: Manage your bankroll over the course of the entire 162-game MLB season. Risking half your roll on one game in the middle of July is not smart.

Seasoned bettors break their bankroll into units (a percentage of the overall amount) and stick with a set amount of units for every bet. Being disciplined helps bettors survive bad runs.

New York MLB Betting Sites FAQ


Matthew Asher
Matthew Asher
Product Coordinator and Fact Checker

As the current Product Coordinator and Fact Checker editor for, Matthew Asher has nearly a decade of experience working in public relations and digital media marketing with the Milwaukee Brewers, St. Louis Rams, Detroit Lions and San Francisco 49ers.Matthew is passionate about the sports betting industry and has been known to explain how to bet on the NFL, College Football and other major sports leagues. He is passionate about making sure you have the most up-to-date and correct information about New York betting regulations.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: